Monday, November 30, 2009
Copyright Law
First, I would like to discuss the distinction between a society based on raw material and one based on information. A society based on raw material kind of resembles a farm or a society that does not value education highly. On the other hand, a society based on information is highly intellectual, with technology and many ideas that should not be freely distributed. I think that copyright is certainly more applicable to a society based on information. For example, people can replicate music or movies more readily than something that is not intellectual. It is highly unlikely for someone to replicate a potato or a solid, physical material from a market and sell it. It is possible for someone to copy a farming method, but I don't see that as bad as breaking copyright law. The one who tries to copy the farming method does have to put in the work to produce a product. On the other hand, copying intellectual material is way worse because it is so easy to say, copy a song, without putting in much work. The person who initially came up with a song or work put in all the work or human labor already. Copyright is so much more of an issue in societies based on information. That is a reason why copyright isn't a big issue in the past; many societies were not intellectual or based on information.
Secondly, I think that Copyright is very important. People do have a right own their information. I totally agree with the humanitarian origin of copyright. To take someone's new, original idea away from that person is analogous to taking a part of that person's brain away. People do need the credit they deserve for a work. The time and effort someone spends on an intellectual work should be recognized. It is not right to break copyright laws. It is like plagiarism, which is highly not tolerated in many institutions of education these days. In this sense, patents should be supported and it is not wrong for someone to want to get rich off an innovative idea. That being said, the more steps needed in order for a work to be published, the worse the situation becomes. Publishers, or other people who authors/composers need to see before making their work final and out to the public, should not be legitimate working men. I am sure that publishers have to sign agreements before they look at an author's work, but it is still an unnecessary step in the process of making intellectual property and distributing it to the public. The extra step of handing a work to a publisher to have it printed takes extra time, and the author could publish his or her own work. This idea may be radical and against the law, but it is a suggestion I have. It would be nice to simplify society and lower the number of steps required to publish and distribute intellectual work. Without the publishers, the work of an author may be more pure and the probability of breaking Copyright laws can be reduced.
I would also like to discuss sausage factories. I liked comparing this to Upton Sinclair's The Jungle earlier today to show the horrific nature of producing meat. They are disgusting, but I find that there should be one reason why we should take pity on some members of society and respect the work they do. Even though the quality of labor may not be good, as seen by occasional fingers sticking out of meat loaves and hair in dishes, due to the unsanitary conditions of the factory, I feel that the producers are doing the best they can given the conditions of the working place. I feel that overall, our society should give more respect to people like these, even though this situation is less common in the world today. Without them, our world would be much different. It is just like we need material imported from China, our world would be much different without this trading partner we have. We cannot produce some material that China can produce. Even though the quality of some work is not good, we should still respect it for what it is. Same thing goes with copyright, we should respect authors and composers for working hard on their intellectual works.
Finally, I do agree with what's been said earlier about fear deterring certain people from coming up with very innovative ideas.
Sunday, November 29, 2009
Animated News --- Now Kids Can Watch How Crimes Happen
Animated News — Now You Can Watch The Crime Happen Like A Movie
I was just watching the news the other day when I came across a very interesting new-media topic— animated news. Recently, a Taiwanese news publication company, the Apple, has introduced animated recreations of crimes into its daily news program. At the company’s headquarter, hundreds of engineers work to turn materials gathered by field journalists into detailed 3-D animated movies. Bloodshed, live actions of robbery, shooting, rapes etc. you name it, “animated news” covers a wide range of social topics from gang violence and street fights to sexual assaults and domestic violence. And while the company allegedly claims that minors under eighteen years of age are not allowed to view the overtly graphic animations, kids can still download the animated news online and watch the clips either on the computer or on their cell phones. (*An example of a less-violent piece of animated news may be viewed on the following website if anyone is interested: http://www.xcar.com.cn/bbs/viewthread.php?tid=11018964 and
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LEsIkpBSRpc ) Furious parents and educators are concerned that the realistic depictions of violence and inappropriate sexual contents would have negative influence on children. The Tai Pei government too, has imposed a daily fee of 500,000 yuan on the Apple Publication and has ordered the company to stop producing animated news. At the same time, media scholars also resist this “new news movement.” Instead of worrying about kids watching recreations of violent crimes, media scholars are more concerned about the change in the nature of news brought by its latest form(animated news).
“The journalists become scriptwriters and the engineers become directors. All there is to the ‘news’ are just imagined details. So the whole animated news is just fake news in reality,” says Taiwanese media scholar Fengjia Zhuang.
Aside from the concern over the negative impact on the nature of news brought by this animated news movement, there are two fundamental problems that cannot be overseen: violence and sexuality.
Let’s start with sexuality. This past week, we’ve talked about how sexuality is portrayed in video games. In Hot Date, Consalvo argues that the design of characters in video games reflect a traditional social belief that women are vulnerable princess who need to be saved by prince-charmings and that the most influence such video games can have on the player is that the games allow players to explore their identity (sexual-wise) playing as the main character (who is usually a guy). But in animated news, sexuality is a much more dangerous component of the medium. The problem is no longer who is playing prince charming; the problem now is how will guys treat women watching rape or other sexual violence recreations growing up. Similarly, will girls thus assume a weak, victimized image?
Secondly, there is the concern over kids' exposure to violence via new media. Here is something to think about: if we do not want expose kids to violent contents, then why do we produce all sorts of media with violent contents in the first place? In a way, the fault is actually on the adults. According to Baidu's Encyclopedia on animated news, the animated news movement is actually driven by the market for sex and violence. If that sentence does not make sense, think of it this way: since the daily news program is converted to animated news which primarily covers news on violent, sexual crimes and even suicides, the entire news spectrum is then converted to violent and sexual contents. Now you may ask why there is this conversion from traditional news to animated news. More specifically, you should ask why such conversion is necessary or unavoidable. The answer is actually quite simple—because sex and violence sells. Remember that article we read earlier on violent video games and kids? The author of that article argues that adults are more afraid of children mastering technologies better than adults do than they are afraid of kids being exposed to violence via video games. But perhaps what adults should really be afraid of is the consequence of their subconscious (or is it?) preference for sex and violence. The entertainment industry will not stop selling sex and violence unless there is no market for it. And until then, good luck to the parents and educators who strive to keep children safe from media contents inappropriate for the kids’ age.
Huiling P.
Thursday, November 26, 2009
No Longer Lessig's "Free Culture"
I went ahead and wrote about Lawrence Lessig's piece on Free Culture for this week's blog post. I hope this is acceptable.
The dramatic shift from a ‘“free culture’” as described by Lawrence Lessig to one dominated by fear, in which everyone is afraid of being sued for accidentally ‘copying’ another’s patented material in their artworks/inventions, reveals a flaw in today’s definition of piracy. Lessig’s initial example of how the ‘who owns what?’ issue (in which the Causby’s argued the Wright brother’s airplanes were trespassing on their airspace, causing their chickens to die) was resolved in favor of the airplane creators. However, it's clear that those who violate some established societal norms with their creativity are increasingly on the receiving end of punishment, which clearly points to the deterioration of our “free culture”.
As mentioned by Lessig in his later chapters, the world-famous character Mickey Mouse was actually copied from the show Steamboat Bill Jr. Walt Disney, fascinated by the success of the film, created a direct parody of it in what was later called ‘Steamboat Willie.’ As this film became a success, Disney reaped profits off of more tales he didn’t create - reinventing the stories from the Brother’s Grimm with happy endings; today’s disney classics. Ironically, the copyright for Mickey Mouse and his friends is still enforced today. Every 20 or so years when the copyright is about to expire, Walt Disney lobbies Congress to lengthen the number of years a character can be copyrighted. Mickey Mouse is now over 80 years old! Corporate greed dominates a culture to the extend that one cannot recreate the world’s most beloved character without facing penalties for copyright infringement.
Other horror stories exist, such as copyrights on songs that are now integral to our culture, including “Happy Birthday to You”. Piracy seems to harm all aspects of creativity- one can not create a song without being sued for ‘copying’ a series of chords (as Coldplay was sued for Viva la Vida), one cannot invent more efficient equipment without being smothered by a dominant company (as Armstrong was nailed by the RCA for inventing FM radio), one cannot create characters in a book without being questioned (J.K. Rowling was sued for Harry Potter). It appears that the idea of ‘piracy’ has been used too much to stifle creativity; it has become a misnomer in todays society.
Tuesday, November 24, 2009
You've got to be kidding me
Mia Consalvo – Hot Dates and Fairy-Tale Romances
When creating new characters, there are a variety of features and appearances that are used to put together a new individual. Race is a big factor of a new character as skin tones are only given in so many tones and usually there is a maximum dark skin tone that isn’t really all that dark. The default Sims that first pops up is a light-complexioned, middle-aged male. This relates to the idea that this is the norm in American society and all other skin tones and gender have to initially start from it and kind of see it as its maker or founder. The limited range of body types shows that people are expected to fall under certain umbrella sizes. Until recently, there was only one large Sims that was significantly overweight.
The Sims allows for a neighborhood to be built and from there on, society grows and changes as a real one would. Fairy tales can be created from this game as characters can be controlled and whatever the user wants to happen can happen. Society is lost in having the perfect relationship or the perfect wedding when sometimes complete perfection can be outright scary. Mistakes are part of being human as we learn from our mistakes and grow with experience. “To err is human, to forgive is divine.” –Alexander Pope.
Gagan Kular =]
Sexuality in Video Games
I agree with Mia and Stephen Poole when they argue that players identify with their characters. Their arguments of player- character identification differ in terms of how the character is drawn and/or portrayed. From Mia’s perspective by having characters such as Zidane drawn with the bare minimum of details, players are presented with a better opportunity to imagine themselves as the character. This identification allows players to imagine the characters personality, actions, and how they relate to other characters. From Poole’s perspective players are more likely to identify with realistic characters than with abstract ones. Based on my limited experience of playing video games, my perspective of player-character identification is similar to Poole’s. When I play Pac-man or any other game where the characters are just shapes with smiley faces, I do not feel bad when they die because I think about the additional lives that they have. Now when I use realistic characters and have been able to grow attached to them, I feel so bad when they die because I think that the characters depended on me and I just let them down. Regardless of how a character is drawn, players will identify with them to varying degrees.
The erotic triangle involves two men who have homosocial feelings towards one another that are displaced onto a woman, who “serves as a placeholder for their heterosexuality”. Examples of the erotic triangle appear in male-buddy action movies such as Superbad, Wedding Crashers, and even Shrek. I have never thought much of the male- buddy relationship as being part of an erotic triangle. In my opinion, the men are really good friends who can identify with the other as a brother. It’s strange that it’s “normal” for girls to be best friends but out of place for guys to be best friends. The latter statement has been recently addressed by the newly created term “bromance”. Society is slowly accepting these intense male friendships.
Monday, November 23, 2009
Hot Dates, etc.
Another point that Consalvo brings up is the love triangle between two men and a woman. I did not think of this in class, but another good movie example of this triangle could be Star Wars. Luke Skywalker, the main character, and Han Solo end up being pretty good friends throughout the series. However, they both inadvertently end up indirectly fighting over Princess Leia. George Lucas relieves this tension by revealing in the end that Princess Leia is, in fact, Luke's sister. There are also many other cases of movies where the main character and his good/best friend end up fighting over a girl between them. These movies usually end with one agreeing to let the other have her or it turning out to be that neither really wants her. They then go back to being good friends and everyone lives happily ever after. The usual story book ending by Hollywood.
So in retrospect, Consalvo brings up the points that show our society is still afraid to admit gays into open media. Apart from Broke Back Mountain, I can not really think of any widely popular movies that featured such a famous gay scene. And in most video games homosexuality is completely avoided, probably for several reasons. One, the game creators may be against homosexuality. Or two, they may be afraid that some people would not buy their game if it was advertised for having homosexuality in it. It is probably a combination of the two, especially considering marketing is what drives most video games to huge sales. In conclusion, I think our society is too afraid to openly address gays and so it will continue to be an unspoken trait for years to come.