Friday, October 9, 2009

Air - fantasy or science? Does it matter?

I am actually going to do my post on "Collective Intelligence" and I think I will post it in about an hour, but I just really want to make some comments on Air following our discussion in class regarding whether Air is more “fantasy” or “science”, and the questions “does how real the science of Air is really matter?”

To answer that question, I think we should answer another question first and the question is – does it hinder the delineation of the author’s messages if we take Air as totally unrealistic? From what I heard in class, most of us agree that it doesn’t; we can still grasp the social commentary in the novel even if we take it as a fantasy novel. Therefore someone (sorry I can’t remember your name, I’ve tried recalling it for the last thirty minutes to no avail) proposes that the author should make Air just that – a fantasy novel. The author should not try to justify the science at all. But I think that the author should try to justify the science. Because I believe the author’s ultimate purpose is to comment on our society, not the society in the novel (which is fictional). The various parallels and links between the society in the novel and our society show that while Ryman is writing about some fictional society, he really wants to say things regarding the society we are living in today. The reason he tries to give us some science in the novel is thus to make his case of urgency and connection. Guaranteed his science does not stand on solid ground and is not realistic, but that is not the point. The point is that merely suggesting Air to be based on actual science helps to serve Ryman’s purpose. So instead of dissecting how “un-science” Air is, we as readers should accept and get by with the idea that Air is science-based and thus feel the urgency of all the real points the novel is trying to make.

Some may then say that Ryman should make Air more scientific: if he really wants to make the connection between the Air world and our world, why not make it totally, completely, one-hundred percent believable? But there is a reason for Ryman to render the Air world unfamiliar, foreign, distant, and yes, somewhat fantasy-like. I think I mentioned, in an earlier class discussion, my reason for this claim: to distance the readers from the Air world helps the readers see the world more clearly and objectively. And as it is our society that Ryman is trying to comment on, he wants to distance our society from us. Thus he creates a fictional world that appears to be foreign and unfamiliar to readers upon first glances, but of course if readers dig deeper they can see the connections and parallels. As we conceive Air to be something that is not our real life, we can judge it more objectively and comprehensively than we would if we were asked to judge our society, because then we inevitably have to start with a personal perspective, and this perspective is more often than not shaded by some sort of bias, albeit very unintentionally. This is not to say that we cannot judge our society objectively; it is possible to do so. It's just much harder. To help the readers easily gain an objective – or at least, a new – point of view, Ryman creates unfamiliarity and distance between the Air world and our world.

So I think that while we can go on debating about how realistic Air is, to grasp the main ideas of the novel we really need to accept what Ryman tells us in terms of how realistic Air is: it’s not something that will happen in our life (at least in some time), and it’s possible that Ryman himself does not think it could (ever) happen, but it is somehow science-based (and just exactly what that “somehow” is does NOT matter) so it could happen. That’s the premise Ryman gives, and it’s the best premise for this book because it serves to help convey his ideas. Therefore the best thing for us to do as readers is perhaps to just go along with it, and go examine the real contents and main points of the novel.

Thursday, October 8, 2009

I just read the piece on collective intelligence and I am intrigued but also noticed some potential problems. Pierre talks about how democracy is going to be expanded to the point where everyone can vote over the Internet and form mini centralized governments inside of each community that would constitute larger governments. These larger governments would then possibly construct one centralized government that would determine the best laws and policies for the whole human race. This would have an advantage to our current form of democracy because it would bind all actions of one country (assuming there are still countries in this futuristic view) with the reaction or consequences to the rest of the world. For example, America is content to accept low priced and generalized goods but is unable to produce most of these goods at these low prices. This has caused companies to set up in third world countries to supply the cheap labor to supply these goods. In the future Pierre describes, the central government will not only have to deal with the need for goods but will also have to deal with the poor working conditions and the meager few cent wages for the people in these undeveloped parts of the world. In that sense this future, this will bring the world together and hopefully achieve a greater common good.

I also see some down sides to the proposal of unified and easily accessed democracy. Democracy is designed for people who are intelligent enough to distinguish and decide between what they want and what society needs. Everyone wants poverty, global warming and problems in health care fixed, but how many of those people actually want to pay to have those problems fixed? When was the last time there was a strike to rally the people to raise taxes so the government could fund hospitals or schools? Combining the vote of the whole world to make laws would boil down to who has the largest population to determine who gets what they want. This would benefit a particular group while possibly hindering the rest of the people. This actually ties into the second problem I would like to address, the division of who gets to vote on specific issues. Stanford should not get a vote on our student government and I should not be able to vote on how laws governing some foreign country I have no affiliation to. Everyone should have a say in a government designed to benefit all of mankind, but it would be extremely difficult to determine a law that would apply to everyone everywhere. It is hard to picture this future working.
This started as a comment but I got a little carried away. I do like the concept of an expanded democracy, but I am a weary on how this government will establish. The idea of a collected intelligence that is based on democracy, theology and information provides an in depth look at the future of global interactions and the impacts they will have on everyday people. This will hopefully be the biases for a new and more efficient interaction between people and government and will allow for a united front for the human race.
Kevin Campbell

Funny Rhetoric picture; "Argumentative Hierarchy"


(CLICK TO ENLARGE)

I found this picture on a science blog once, and thought it was amusingly related to this course. (This isn't my blog post though, it can be found further down)


Air and Schizophrenia/Multiple Personality Disorder

One of the passages in the book which struck me as very climactic and which provided good examples of Airs' variety of strange effects and "features" was the passage between pages 192 and 196, in which Mae battles her body's possession by Old Mrs. Tung. We spoke shortly about this passage in class, but I would like to provide a more elaborate comparison. While speaking to an intelligent desk providing a lesson about the "U.N. format" and politics around Air, Mae is suddenly "possessed" by the soul of Old Mrs. Tung. During a battle of minds, where Mae desperately tries to regain control over her body, Old Mrs. Tung and Mae exhange dialogue using the only media available - Mae's voice and body.

The effect created, namely, that two voices are spoken through only Mae, instantly reminded me of schizophrenia and/or multiple personality disorder. People with these mental diseases, especially schizophrenia, have been observed to "demonstrate [...]  disorganized and unusual thinking and speech." (Wikipedia) To draw an analogy, Air emulates the effects (such as "word salad") of these conditions through the sci-fi qualities of Air. To me, this helps to provide a solid reference frame in reality, as to comprehend the extent of Mae's and Old Mrs. Tung's situation. This "tool" of metaphors is very often employed by science fiction stories, and I think Geoff Ryman creates an interesting new use of the tool . A lot of sci-fi terms we take for granted today do actually have analogy-driven roots - such as "shield," "ship" and "(star)gate."

Without previous references to word salads uttered by schizophreniacs and from other sources, I would have had lots of trouble making sense of this passage. The idea here is that the concept that two souls or minds may exist in one single body has already been introduced to me. Without such an introduction, this passage in particular would be difficult to comprehend. For example, I would have considered the sentence fragment "Someone answered Mae aloud" (pg. 192) very confusing or some kind of play of words (which, it in some sense is, but it is a plot device rather than a linguistic method.)

Wednesday, October 7, 2009

About the craziness

I had a thought toward the end of class about the style of the book and the strange things Ryman included in the book. I see the book as broken up into three parts so far. In the first part, Ryman introduced Air which was strange but, I think, a reasonable thing for this type of book. In the second part, things go nuts with Mae's stomach baby and a talking dog. The third part that we read for today was like the beginning with nothing completely unfathomable happening.

Part of the change has to do with setting. The first and third parts take place in Mae's village and the second part mainly takes place in a different town and in the lab. Regardless of how realistic everything is, I think the changes are meant to suggest something about how people in different positions vary in their use of the technologies that become available to them. Mae and some of the villagers are using Air for business and to preserve the history of the Eloi. The government and Mr. Tunch's goals are much more questionable and bizarre.

-Rolando

Saturday, October 3, 2009

Just to Clarify...

In response to questions raised regarding my view on the whole patriarchy thing, I just want to clarify that what I wrote in the blog entry was purely an observation about the similarity between King Lear, A Thousand Acres, and Air. I had no intention whatsoever to start a grand debate about whether it would be good or not good to go back to a complete patriarchal society.

Best,

Huiling P.

Friday, October 2, 2009

Shakespeare, Smiley, Air Style

I was never a fan of science fictions. All the mad talks about aliens, robot conspiracies, fancy technological inventions, humanities being reduced to a lesser state and so on only gave me the impression that the author is over paranoid if not nuts. But Ryman’s Air was a bit different. To be honest, when my exhausted self attempted to do the assigned reading at eleven o'clock at night, the technical details of the air system naturally blurred and slipped away as soon as the words finished passing through my brain. For the most part, the twisted relationships between the heroine, Mae, and her fellow villagers kept me reading. Yet, even just casually skimming the text, I could not help but notice a striking similarity between the storyline, and after further pondering, even the theme, in Geoff Ryman's Air and that of Jane Smiley's adaptation of Shakespeare's King Lear, A Thousand Acres.

First of all, both stories have similar settings. Air took place in a rural village bordering the Middle East and the village’s primary source of living comes from farming; A Thousand Acres, similarly, took place in a remote farming town. Mae and Ginny are both farm wives and obviously non-traditional ones too. Mae and Ginny were never happy with the institutions in which they lived and the system around which everything works. But their lack of exposures to new ideas and things kept them safely boxed in the accepted social norm. However, as drastic changes get brought about, and things get set off at the chaotic end, Mae and Ginny gains freedom to pursue what their heart truly desires. Under the veneer protection of change, Mae and Ginny have affairs outside of their marriage and expand their participation in “men’s business.” But they both neglected a very important thing: the chaos brought about by the change is a chain reaction, it does not stop at any point. The discovery of Mae’s affair with Mr. Ken and Mr. Shen’s constant opposition against her school to teach Air were examples of never-ending chaos.

Now, recall the source of crisis in King Lear, the King’s family, system, and everything in the kingdom falls apart when he divides his land among his daughters, which equates introducing female dominance into a patriarchic world. Air seems to be on the same track too. As Air is introduced to the folks in Kizulda, people change and bad things start happening. Friends become enemies and some individuals (Mrs. Ken) even go as far as committing suicide in resisting the change. And perhaps, as is implied in both King Lear and A Thousand Acres, changes are not good. So is Ryman trying to deliver a message that extreme technological development will in the end doom us all? That, may just be the question we readers shall ponder as we continue our reading for this book.

Huiling Pan
Oct. 2, 2009